Goodbye PDA, Hello iPod?
Pages: 1, 2
Text Notes
Before you can use the text notes feature, there are two things you should do:
- Enable the Firewire Disk Usage of your iPod. You need to do this to use the notes feature at all. (see Using your iPod as a Hard Disk for instructions)
- Activate AppleScript's "Script Menu" utility. By doing this, you can install utilities to create notes from the clipboard and other neat things.
In its simplest form, you can simply drag text files into the Notes
directory on your iPod. When using the iPod, just use the
I find that sometimes the list of notes did not appear on the iPod: if I press "Menu" to back up again and reselect Notes, the list pops right up. Between this and the slow calendar response, it seems likely that some software updates may be coming--or at least needed--in the near future.
Enabling the Script Menu utilities
The Script Menu is
installed with Mac OS X 10.2, but to use the iPod scripts from Apple,
you'll need to activate it, if you haven't already. Just open your
Applications folder, find the AppleScript folder, and double-click on the
ScriptMenu.menu folder icon (or drag it to menu bar).
|
|
Then download the iPod
scripts library; just copy the iPod folder into the
|
|
To create a note, make sure your iPod is connected as a hard disk and then copy the text for the note to the clipboard (you can select the text from any application it happens to be in). Then use the "Clipboard to Note" item on your Script Menu. You'll be prompted for a title for your note, and it will be created with that title as a filename in the "Notes" directory of your iPod.
|
|
More than Just Plain Text
The notes functionality of the iPod has some other interesting
features. It actually supports a subset of html tags, including linking
to other notes or even songs. Supported html tags include
<p></p>, <br> and <a
href>. I tried <b> and
<i> tags, but they don't appear to be supported. The
XHTML-correct <br /> is not supported. It displays the
code rather than inserting a line break.
Here's an example of some markup within a note:
<p>To create a note, copy the text for the note to the
clipboard (you can select the text from any application it happens to be
in), and then use the "Clipboard to Note" item on your Script
Menu.</p>
<p><a href="Instructions">View the
more instructions here</a>.</p>
In this example, the link to "Instructions" will take the reader to the note of that same name. Links are underlined when displayed on the iPod, and followed by pressing the "select" button. If there are multiple links, the scroll wheel can be used to move between them.
Song linking can include using filters to create temporary playlists of songs. An example from the Apple documentation is
<a href="ipod:music?genre=rock&artist=Brian Eno">Combo</a>
For more juicy details, see the iPod Note Reader User Guide (a PDF file) from the iPod section of the Apple Developer Connection.
No Input? That Might Change...
Perhaps the biggest barrier to using an iPod as a PDA is the lack of any way to input any data while you're on the move and away from your computer. But it's possible that this may change...soon.
As first reported on iPoding, the iPod's diagnostic mode reveals a recording feature, and you can actually try it out now:
- Hold down the "Menu" and "Play/Pause" buttons (the two center buttons in the top row) until the Apple logo appears.
- Press and hold down, in this order, the center button (inside the dial) and then "Previous" and "Next" (the two outside buttons in the top row). The Apple logo disappears--release buttons and you'll hear a chirp and see a "reverse" logo before the diagnostics menu appears.
- Use the "Next" button to scroll thru the choices until you reach "J. Record".
- Press the center button (inside the dial) and you'll see "Recorder"--have your left headphone ready to use as a microphone.
- When you see "BEGIN" in the menu, start talking into the headphone for about 6 seconds.
- When the time is over, you'll see "DONE". Press the center button to play back your recording.
- Press Play/Pause to return to the diagnostic menu
- I'm not sure of the proper way to exit diagnostic mode, but I found that I can press and hold "Menu" and "Play/Pause" again until the Apple Logo appears, and then release it and wait a few seconds to be returned to your iPod's usual main menu
Of course, this doesn't seem to be good for anything yet. I haven't been able to find any sound files stored on the device so that I can retrieve a short voice memo. But it appears that the capability for such a feature exists, so it's an exciting possibility for the future.
So Is it Time to Retire the PDA?
As usual, it depends. If you use your PDA for more than small notes, contacts and calendaring, or if you do frequent input using your PDA, the PDA-like features of the iPod are going to seem anemic at best.
If you mainly use your PDA as a look-up device for contacts, events, and a small amount of other information, the iPod may be all you need. I really like the readability that's been packed into the small screen area. I find it easier to read than the larger characters on my PDA. Navigating the address book would be easier with support for groups, and it would be nice to have a way to create notes on the computer and then have them synch to the iPod later, without having to have the iPod connected to create a note.
The iPod certainly has some distance to go if it's ever to become a full-featured PDA replacement (and that may not be the plan, after all). But for my money and pocket space, I think this is going to be just the ticket. I may have to figure out how to sell something on eBay next.
Terrie Miller likes to work on articles while listening to the Pretenders.
Return to the Mac DevCenter.
You must be logged in to the O'Reilly Network to post a talkback.
Showing messages 1 through 29 of 29.
-
Goodbye PDA, Hello IOPOD or IPDA
2005-09-28 18:00:00 radams [Reply | View]
I think you are right since the pda seems very slow in resembling anything like a computer in the hand. I think apple could carry this ipod finaticism over to a computer like IOPOD with IO as it's main strength, along with a mini osx, but full featured.Slow serial, (slow usb and bluetooth) seem to be as fast an io as most pda makers want to mess with. I am surprised Apple hasn't taken advantage of this ipod craze. People want a real hand held computer that is from apple but cheap. Let it run a mni wondows or mac os x. Are you listening Steve.
-
iPod + Screen
2003-05-21 05:40:47 studuncan [Reply | View]
I wonder whether the next iPod might have a screen (6 inch at 800x600) and be the visual equivalent of the iPod. With firewire & USB, you could use it to carry movies, TV programmes (recorded via EyeTV?) or transfer digital camcorder recordings to it and edit them (as well as music). I don't see Apple producing a Newton for the new millenium, but a digital visual device might be a seller. Particularly with all that hard disk space. -
iPod + Screen
2003-05-21 06:41:01 Terrie Miller | [Reply | View]
Hm...sounds about the size of the rumored mini-tablet.
It seems there's always something to look forward to with Apple.
-
HTML tags
2003-05-16 02:34:55 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Have you tried and instead of and . The former two would be more likely to work in newer implementations. -
HTML tags
2003-05-18 11:42:05 Terrie Miller | [Reply | View]
Thanks for your note,. Yes -- I tried <em> and <strong> (Emphasis and Strong) instead of italic and bold -- but got the same results.
-
Stickies...
2003-05-11 07:09:20 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Why not make stickies iSync-able? Then perhaps I can have the option of synching it with the memo pad on my Sony Clié (PalmOS) or with the new iPod Notes.
Andy Macaulay.
-
My iPod Life
2003-05-09 20:55:25 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
One of the stupid things about our modern tech stuff is fumbling around for all those things: cell phone, PDA, iPod, cd/tape/MD, oh yeah, laptop ad infinitum.
Hey, I'm just as geeky as the next person (here) but I hate all the tiny luggage. I don't hate this stuff without trying it...
I carried an Emate as my main portable for 2 years (and a
Newton100 before that).So after I sold that off, I decided I'd wait until something better came along.
For me, Cellphones suck and drain bank accounts. I can't even stand to wear a watch. But for about a year and half
I've been using an ipod for data, contacts, and "tech tools" and -wow, around 600 songs from my 18 gig song library (Blues, Zappa, Dylan and Beck get a fair amount of random airplay in my head).
Aside from having to actually sync stuff regularly (I do
it at my bequest, iSync needs tweaking a bit) and remembering to charge it up, the ipod has served me well
so far.
I know some folks ( I see them on the subway) enjoy poking
at something on their Palms and ipaq things, but after
knowing what these are and what the Newton was...yeesh
depression. (ipaq users, check out Mochaworks..ditch the MS) I digress, 98% of what I need (offline) access to is in my iPod - as well as Sea Change, and Roxy and Elsewhere.
For me, Less is discretely more.
-
Why not?
2003-05-09 13:48:25 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Funny thing that this article came out as soon as I decided to dump my Palm. Yes sounds crazy after years of owning pda's, but I was getting tired of carrying (and remembering) so many gadgets.
I use iPodit with Entourage and it syncs everything including news, weather and icals. 95% of the time I'm just viewing my info for the day and if I need to input info I usually use my cell phone calendar or write an email from the office to home. I only carry 2 devices now and my jacket is lighter!
It gets the job done for myself, of course not for everyone. But I don't want to buy a Zire to input info and carry another device b/c it's cheap to do so. I love my ipod and with so much space why not carry other stuff. I wish there were some games though to download and install!
-
iPod PDA
2003-05-07 13:47:28 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Are Apple affraid of history repeating itself, because as non iPod user [I know, I know] all I ever seem to see is people using their iPod for anything but listening to music. The iPod has become the spiritual successor to the Newton .. though not as well endowed[!]
Apple really ought to be taking note here. They have a killer device that is already being used in ways above and beyond it's original purpose.
Or is this is some sly plan of Apples to test the water in pre-emption of something more sophisticated?
-
Not quite there yet
2003-05-06 19:29:40 clvrmnky [Reply | View]
My Palm III died recently so I thought I'd review the iPod to see if it can review 90% of what I use a PDA for.
It just didn't measure up.
-
Extending the functionality...
2003-05-06 18:02:31 jeffspam [Reply | View]
Because of the iPod's interface limitations (which are designed for an mp3 player), it won't replace my PDA any time soon. But give the iPod bluetooth and then I'll sync ONLY the iPod (not the PDA), and use that as my "quick and dirty" information device. When I need something more full-featured, I can whip out my PDA and have it wirelessly utilize the data on the iPod. -
notebook vs. desktop users
2003-05-07 09:00:40 Terrie Miller | [Reply | View]
When I read your message I couldn't help but imagine carrying a notebook/laptop, a PDA, *and* an iPod. But then I realized that not everyone has portable computers.
If I didn't have an iBook, but used a desktop machine for day-to-day stuff instead, I think I'd definitely want a full-featured PDA. But because the iBook is so handy most of the time, I really don't feel the pain of no input with the iPod.
-
iPod as PDA - usefulness
2003-05-06 14:33:57 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Just a quick note to respond to the use of an iPod as a PDA.
I own a 30GB iPod and a Palm Zire.
Why both?
- The Palm's 1,000s of apps can't be used on the 'Pod.
- I bought the Zire (>$90) the evening that I realized that I couldn't swap my contact info via IR with a new acquaintance who was carrying his Handspring. Had to enter it by hand. Glad I that bought the Zire. I used the IR business card beaming feature within the next month to make business contacts and get the job.
- Can't even enter the data directly into the iPod if I want to. Tried carrying a paper and pencil, but found I forgot it at home too often.
Also tried using a Sony Palm 760c for a year. Works fine as a PDA, but falls very short as an MP3 player... especially in capacity (128MB max until very recently). Also falls terribly short on the battery life... a week of standby at most. Have to keep it in its cradle.
Why a Zire?
- Cheap.
- Works.
- Recharges via a standard mini-B USB connector (digital camera style) while you sync. Neato.
- No need to carry its power brick on trips... it goes for about a month... beating every other device in its class that I've used. (It's my 3rd Palm OS device in 5 years).
- Enter data on the go.
- Beam data on the go. Even to Pocket PC with an app that can reformat the data for them.
Just thought these were relevant to the topic of how useful an iPod serves as a PDA.
Practical crtieria for a PDA (in fashion that I use 'em):
1. Should not require frequent recharging. Longer the battery life the better. Rechargeable a plus, but make sure you replace it. iPod doesn't fair well here. A week of standby battery charge without plugging it into the Powerbook vs. the Zire's month-long charge.
2. Should be able to alter/enter/move data on the go without a computer. I've used the Palm IR beaming feature to my financial benefit many times over the last five years. iPod fails this criteria. Zire does fine on all of these.
3. Simplicity is a must. Featuritis (and poor battery life) was the reason that I gave up on the Sony MP3-playing Palm. iPod meets this criteria very well. Interface is quite straight-forward, requiring only 2-3 seconds to locate the contact info. 4-5 seconds to locate a date/appointment. Zire's UI takes just a little bit longer than that in both tasks.
Sooo... I use my iPod daily for both music and phone numbers. It is often the electronic doodad that I look up a phone number in because it is clipped on my belt (GEEK). I autosync my Entourage X contact/calendar (the main PIM on my Powerbook) every time I sync the music.
The Zire also comes with me every day in the backpack (which is a constant commuting companion). Don't think about it, but it is always in my pack and only needs charging once a month. Zire and iPod sync to the same database of info (Entourage X) so there is little or no discrepancies between them.
Jonathan Woolson -
iPod as PDA - usefulness
2003-05-07 09:14:53 miky [Reply | View]
I feel that the definition of PDA (Personal Digital Assistant) somewhat degraded since the times of Apple's Newton. I can hardly imagine usefulness of any PDA if i can get no snippet of info *into* it without use of a desktop computer (uh, +custom accessories now). Frankly, i tend not to label devices that dump all information down the drain due to dead batteries as PDAs either. Maybe that's why i still stick to my MP2100? ;)
-
taking advantage of all those gigabytes
2003-05-06 14:32:16 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
As a giant hd (the largest one is 375x bigger than the 80mb hd that sat under my Mac Plus) the iPod could have some really neat features.
I know I'm not the first one to think that the ability to transfer images from a digital camera to the iPod would be a great value added feature. While IBM Microdrives have gotten cheaper, they are still by no means cheap. Furthermore, tourists could really benefit from having infinite photo storage. Now, with the new USB compatible connection, camera syncing seems technically possible.
regards,
Ari -
taking advantage of all those gigabytes
2003-05-09 20:30:57 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Unfortunately, as I understand it, USB data transfer requires a host (computer), where FireWire does not. So for instance you could (technically, if Apple let you) transfer data between iPods via FireWire, but not via USB. Considering that most digital still cameras use USB, I wouldn't count on this happening. Too bad, because if I could use an iPod like a Digital Wallet, I'd already have one, rather than still be waiting for one to hit my price/performance sweet spot. :-(
-
that would be *sweet*! (eom)
2003-05-07 08:55:31 Terrie Miller | [Reply | View]
-
Excellent!
2003-05-06 14:28:29 Kevin Hemenway |
[Reply | View]
After finally deciding I "needed" a PDA (the sole desire being to carry about large lists of information to compare whilst shopping), and getting heartfully discouraged by the sheer selection and time I'd need to invest to make the "right choice", I happenstanced upon the new iPod's note feature. Which was, as they say, exactly what I needed. I didn't want wireless. I didn't want to install new programs. I didn't want an OS or a stylus. I wanted an electronic list. Further exploration with the calendar capability solidified it - now, I could carry around lists of DVD release dates too. Wonderful!
This article was very timely for me - here's hoping I get my new iPod far before the "on or before May 12th" date. Much as you linked to the PDF on the notes, I had seen that a few days ago, and have already started creating "theatre showtime to iPod" conversion scripts. Thanks from a fellow O'Reilly author (happily enough, Mac OS X Hacks, advertised midway through). -
Excellent!
2003-05-06 17:27:19 Terrie Miller | [Reply | View]
Thanks! I've been enjoying Mac OS X Hacks, too!
Using lists is a *big* reason I wanted to check out the text notes feature. Lists of books I'd like to look thru if I happen to find myself in a bookstore, lists of movies I can't find on Netflix in case I'm passing by the video rental store, etc.
-
iSync options
2003-05-06 14:16:39 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
The reason you can select multiple calendars to sync, but only one address group, seems to me that events belong to just one calendar, while persons can belong to multiple groups. I have to admit, though, that this is a lame excuse, but it qualifies as one. Doesn't it?
-- Jan. -
iSync options
2003-05-06 17:34:40 Terrie Miller | [Reply | View]
That's a good point. It *is* sort of lame, but I'd at least feel better knowing there was a reason for it! An event has to belong to a calendar, but a contact does not have to belong to a group.
Somewhere I read that the non-music items on the ipod are actually stored using the same MP3 file fields (though I'm not clear on the details). I'm not sure if that might have anything to do with it or not.
-
Dumping a PDA? Not even close
2003-05-06 07:23:05 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Unless you don't enter data onto your PDA, using the iPod as a PDA is pretty pointless as it lacks the one thing that a PDA needs - DATA ENTRY! Without a competent method for putting data entry on the iPod it gets kind of awkward to get someones information and try to store it :) -
Dumping a PDA? Not even close
2003-05-24 14:43:16 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Some of the things I love about my PDA (Palm Tungsten T) is looking at my fav pix (Photobase) and watching my QuickTime movies (via Kinoma). Give me an iPod with a hi-rez screen and Palm OS - that would be something very special in the PDA realm. -
Dumping a PDA? Not even close
2003-05-11 12:15:13 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Maybe that is why he states to rarely does DATA ENTRY on his PDA.
I was the same so I dumped my PDA for an ipod. -
Dumping a PDA? Not even close
2004-01-07 12:36:50 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
does anyone know if theres a keybaord for it?
I mean, i've seen little qwerty keyboards for phones - they just attach onto the bottom - used for txting.
I'm sure they could do one for the ipod... -
Dumping a PDA? Not even close
2004-01-07 13:44:54 Terrie Miller | [Reply | View]
I haven't seen anything like this, but it's hard to imagine, since there's no interface (keyboard or otherwise) on the iPod for text input -- a PDA or phone usually has some sort of text input method already.
Of course, the microphone and digital photo accessories show that the iPod OS has a way to create new files directly on the iPod, so perhaps there's something already there for text input that just isn't evident yet.
-
VoodooPad Export to the iPod
2003-05-05 15:53:59 Terrie Miller | [Reply | View]
As this article was being prepared, James Duncan Davidson blogged a really interesting note about another note taking option in Wiki Meet iPod -- be sure to check it out if you're interested in making the most of the text note feature of the new iPods.








