Panther Delights
by David Miller12/09/2003
Author's note: If you're looking for the final straw to convince you to upgrade to Panther, this article is certainly not it. This article will not make you a more knowledgeable Mac user. It will not teach you hidden secrets of OS X, and it will not increase your productivity. But maybe it will help you appreciate some of the refinements that Apple has included in Panther, its latest major release of Mac OS X. After all, aren't those extra touches what we've come to expect from Apple?
On its page for Panther,
Apple boasts of "150
innovative new features" available in Panther. Those who have been using
Panther since its release have certainly noticed at least some of the
functional improvements (such as integrated faxing
and increased security), while
readers of Mac DevCenter who haven't already upgraded to Panther might
have already read James Duncan
Davidson's article
titled "Top 10 Things I Dig About Panther", in which he outlines his
favourite 10 11 of the 150 new features in Panther.
However, none of that "improved functionality" stuff will be mentioned
here. As Mac users, we've come to expect the very best from our pal
with the blue smiley face (whether he's housed in candy-coloured plastic
or brushed metal). And with that high expectation comes the eye candy
that OS X is famous for, for better or for worse.
|
Related Reading
Mac OS X: The Missing Manual, Panther Edition |
In this article I'll pay tribute to some of the features of OS X that have been revamped in Panther. These "improvements" will not be of the kind that finally convinces you to upgrade. In fact, you might even consider them to be frivolous, as the "improvements" listed here are almost purely aesthetic. But this list is what separates Apple from the rest of the pack; no other company puts more spit and polish into its products than Apple, and with Panther it really shows. It's like buying a new car and discovering a cup holder tucked away in the dash; it's a nice feature, but you bought the car for other reasons (I hope).
So I kicked the tires, took Panther for a spin around the block, and decided to take the plunge. And after breaking her in for a couple weeks and finding out what's under the hood, the following is a list of my favourite cup holders in OS X 10.3 (in no particular order). If there's something in Panther that you think should be included on this list, post it in the TalkBacks at the end of the article, and let's see how long a list we can make.
#1. System Authentication Button
One of the first things you might notice when opening the System
Preferences application is the new lock that sits in the bottom-left
corner of the administration panes. It's now much easier to see from
a glance whether the button indicates a locked or unlocked state, and
the image of the lock "really ties the window together," as The Dude
would say. You might even find yourself inadvertently authenticating
and de-authenticating yourself, simply to watch the animation between
the two states. (Not that I've done that, or anything.)
It should also be noted that the new authentication button hasn't made its way into other administration applications, such as NetInfo Manager. Whether this happens in the future is anyone's guess. And by anyone, I mean Mr. Jobs.
#2. Help Button
Sprinkled throughout dialog boxes in OS X's applications are little
buttons with "?" as the caption. You probably guessed that these are
help buttons: if you aren't sure about what you are getting yourself
into, you can always click on the button to open the corresponding page
in Help Viewer and find out more information before you click another
button. While this behaviour isn't specific to Panther, what is
new is the colour of all the help buttons: purple.
The use of colour on the button emphasizes its unique role, and nicely
complements Aqua's existing colour palette.
#3. Tab View
In an attempt to make the Aqua theme modern, one of its major components
is the use of rounded corners in lieu of square corners. Indeed, OS
X 10.0's interface seemed much more friendly than OS 9, as it introduced
rounded corners on buttons, window title bars, and other elements.
You can now add tab-view panes to that list as well. The difference
between the old appearance and the new is subtle: the view now sports
a slightly recessed appearance, and the tabs have been replaced with
interconnected buttons. I find that the new look results in a sleeker
appearance than Jaguar's views.
#4. Sheets
For users who have spent hours of their lives waiting for the theme-selection dialog in Keynote to appear and disappear whenever they create a new presentation, the new sheet animation in Panther is a blessing. While the new animation in Panther isn't noticeably different from previous versions of the operating system, it is definitely faster. The animation still produces the same effect; it just gets the job done in less time and adds snappiness to an already speedy operating system.
#5. Menu Spacers
Present in OS 9 and previous versions of Mac OS, menu spacers were left out of OS X. Instead, Jaguar relied solely on white space to delineate groups of related menu items. Panther brings the spacers back to menus using a single gray line, in addition to the white space, to produce a subtle distinction from Jaguar and its predecessors. While it's a matter of opinion in preferring one to the other, menu spacers are a tip of the hat to Apple's single-digit operating systems.
#6. Preferences Menu Command
One of the things that Apple succeeded in doing for OS X is creating a standardized structure for menus in Cocoa applications. Windows applications generally share the same sequence of menus ("File", "Edit", etc.), but the contents of those menus is anyone's guess.
Want to change some of the options for your Windows application? You'll have to memorize which menu holds the command (probably "Edit", but sometimes "Tools"), and then you'll have to search through the contents of the menu to find what you're looking for, because it is rarely in a common location. And even then some applications refer to them as "options", and others use "preferences."
Contrast this situation with that of OS X and you'll see how much effort Apple has spent on creating a standard interface (except for the whole brushed-metal thing, but who's counting). Want to change the contents of your toolbar? Click on "View", then "Customize Toolbar..." Want to edit the application preferences? Click on the application menu, and then select the "Preferences" item, which will always be found right below the application group.
While the preferences menu item could always be found in the same place in Jaguar, it didn't always have the same keyboard shortcut; some applications used "Command + ,"; others used "Command + ;"; and some provided no keyboard shortcut at all. As of Panther, Apple seems to have finally decided upon "Command + ," as the standard shortcut to access an application's preferences. I hope the upcoming releases of third-party applications will follow suit. Some applications, such as Photoshop, Illustrator, and Flash, use their own keyboard shortcut, but the applications usually allow users to customize their keyboard shortcuts. Oddly enough, it isn't possible to user Panther's Universal Keyboard Shortcuts to globally define the keyboard shortcut to display an applications' preferences dialog.
Nevertheless, this feature is a huge improvement for those who prefer to keep their fingers on the keyboard as much as possible. But, perhaps more than anything, it's just a nagging loose end that Apple has finally tied up.
#7. Window Texture
The first thing you might notice in the switch between the OS X of old
and the new is the texture of the windows. The recessed appearance of the
widgets in title bars has been slowly making its way into Apple's software. The style was first introduced in Apple's iLife
applications, in addition to other applications such as DVD
Player, iSync,
and Address
Book. The much-maligned pin-stripe effect has also been softened
to produce a much more subtle effect, and the stripes have been completely
removed from the title bar. Being the first change to greet you upon
logging onto Panther, these changes are perhaps the most noticeable
distinctions between Jaguar and Panther.
#8. Launch-Zoom
Previous to OS X, the Finder produced a "zooming rectangle" effect when documents or applications were opened. It was far from pretty, but it got the job done: it's sole mission was to let the user know that the Finder was grinding away. Well, OS X came to town and with Quartz's advanced rendering capabilities, users were treated, until now, with the same "zooming rectangle" effect when opening files from within the Finder.
Panther replaces Jaguar's "zooming rectangle" with the icon of the item that's opening. While it's not a huge difference from the rectangle, it is a little more appealing to the eyes and is out of the way faster, adding to Panther's sense of speed.
#9. Graphic Design
It seems that every new release of iTunes introduces a different appearance for the playback buttons. Raised above the application window? Sunk? Flush with the window? Who knows what will happen next?
In a similar vein, every major release of OS X brings changes in icons and other visual elements of the operating system. I would love to see the number of new interface graphics created solely for Panther and its included applications--the Apple menu, the Finder, and countless other elements of the operating system--sport a shiny new pixel jacket.
10. System Preferences' Stripes
The System Preferences application has undergone a facelift in each of the last two major revisions to OS X. Jaguar brought the ability to sort the preference panes by alphabetical order and by category (such as "Personal" and "Hardware"). And now Panther introduces another change to the application, only this time it's purely cosmetic: the rows of preferences alternate background colour.
Log Out...
Perfection is in the details. And while OS X is still far from being perfect, Apple is making huge improvements in its flagship software with each release (none of those improvements were touched upon here). But appreciating the cup holders in Panther makes you enjoy the Exposés and FileVaults of Apple's latest release that much more. Happy computing.
David Miller is combining his passions of photography and working on the web at iStockphoto; when not hacking away with a text editor and a few web browsers in hand, he can be seen huddled over his laptop tweaking levels and curves for his freelance photography. Keep track of David's latest projects over at his home on the web.
Return to the Mac DevCenter
You must be logged in to the O'Reilly Network to post a talkback.
Showing messages 1 through 29 of 29.
-
not much incentive to switch
2003-12-13 14:07:04 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
-
not much incentive to switch
2003-12-20 09:35:22 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
shops that are still using OS 9 must have good reasons for doing so...probably a cash flow problem, or such like (that gets in the way of upgrading hardware and software)
but asserting that it is because of os 9's "greater stability" indicates that the shop is a coelacanth (a living fossil) whose main job is to put out a biweekly newsletter or something - stable when all you run is Office 98
then again, publishing may not be their strong suit, if their spokesperson is suggesting the "emporer" has no clothes.
-
not much incentive to switch
2004-01-05 10:19:41 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
here are some reasons to still run 9:
1. it works (particularly AppleShare over TCP/IP). My x.2.8 client is always messing up (loses files), and has issues with permissions on both Netatalk and AppleShare IP servers.
2. The apps we need still run on the OS 9 clients, including Office 98!
3. Cash is an issue. Send me your credit card, and I'll be glad to buy new hardware, productivity apps, and backup server.
4. In my experience, with our configuration, OS9 is a far more stable desktop OS. It typically runs more than a month without reboot in our environment. Unlike my linux systems, where, fro example redhat up2date can be run, and then the process hup'ed to avoid a reboot, there seems to be a weekly patch or security update requiring a reboot. And when I run X.2.8 on a laptop, (titanium) we really seem to have trouble (wake from sleep, etc.)
5. I think the MacOS finder, is still more intuitive. In my opinion, the X finder takes some steps back -- I would rather use KDE or windows. Eg., There is no need for the very large 3D graphical representations of folders and docs in X, as this takes excessive screen real-estate.
6. We are prisoners of our own experience, dating back to beta-test Lisa. What tangible benefits do we get by re-wiring all our neurons?
-
Image capture
2003-12-11 01:26:24 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
When importing photos with "Image capture" the slide dipicts a cool cube effect, similar to the one during fast user switching.
-
sheets tear up title bar ...
2003-12-11 00:22:25 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Generally very pleased with the (visual) improvements in Panther, except for the sheets which sometimes (not in all apps) cut out of, and *through* the windows' title bar; just doesn't seem fit for a title bar made of metal ... i liked the old method better. Actually, I think it's appalling!
-
Address Book
2003-12-10 19:42:39 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
I just found another one when I took a new .vcf contact file from Entourage and dropped it into Address Book (where I had an older version). A delightful screen with cool buttons asked me if I wanted to keep the old one, keep the new one, keep both, or update the card. -
Address Book
2003-12-11 07:38:47 David Miller |
[Reply | View]
Definitely a nice feature. I no longer have three different entries in my address book for one person :).
-
Panther Disk Utility
2003-12-10 17:32:36 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Disk Utility is awsome. I've been using Panther for about a month, and I just found out that Disk Copy and Disk Utility are just one app now! Kool!
-
Did anybody notice...
2003-12-10 16:55:43 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
that these are all just visual enhancements? I'm not saying OS X isn't gorgeous and I'm not saying that it isn't a solid OS on the technical side, but just because an OS _looks_ great doesn't automatically mean its improved greatly...
Yes OSX is cute, but lets focus on technical improvements as well... -
Did anybody notice...
2003-12-12 19:56:14 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Technical improvements? Don't know how they do it, but performance is noticeably better on two Tangerine iBooks, plus on one white G3 iBook and one G4 iBook. Zippy. Not a very technical analysis, but the improved speed is evidence of improved technology. -
Did anybody notice...
2003-12-11 06:35:32 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
He repeatedly made mention that he was only listing cosmetic enhancements that reflected a thoughtfulness of design.
100% of my time with Panther is spent interacting with the visual side of it, so I appreciate any efforts Apple takes to make it look better, act better, or work better.
I don't think anyone would disagree with your contention that looks aren't everything, but they would disagree with your use of the word "just" in the first sentence.
-
Live search and word completion
2003-12-10 16:22:55 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Live search works great in Preview, Finder, Mail, iPhoto, iTunes, and many other places. Word completion is everywhere, apart from Word. -
Live search and word completion
2003-12-11 07:45:13 David Miller |
[Reply | View]
Kind of ironic, hey?
-
Sheets Animation
2003-12-10 14:42:43 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
No, the sheets animation is different under Panther. It kind of unfurls like cloth instead of just dropping down flat like in Jaguar. It's subtle, but a very nice change.
-
Redesigned Help pages
2003-12-10 14:34:52 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Another nice touch in Panther is the redesigned Help pages for Finder and the iApps. They seem better organized, and have better start pages than earlier incarnations.
-
Tabs don't look like tabs
2003-12-10 12:35:43 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
While I'm overjoyed as to how well polised OS X is so far, I think Apple made a step backwards with the new appearance of tabs. They don't look like tabs anymore! It makes tabbed panes loose their real world metaphor.
-
finder 'preferences'
2003-12-10 10:53:29 eccentricanomaly [Reply | View]
am I the only one annyoned that a lot of stuff that should be in finder's preferences are in the view menu under 'show view options'? -
finder 'preferences'
2003-12-11 12:10:13 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Show view options doesn't contain system-wide preferences, they're folder-specific options. -
finder 'preferences'
2003-12-11 12:28:24 eccentricanomaly [Reply | View]
I would consider the Desktop to be a systemwide preference... but configuring it involves three different preference panes: system preferences, finder's preferences, and the view options... to set background color, get rid of HDD icon and then to set the icon size on the Desktop. This annoys me :(
-
Panther Delights
2003-12-10 07:38:00 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Address Book - Adding a vCard for a name that exists in the Address Book.
You get a choice of how the information is added; keep the old vCard, keep the new vCard, keep both or update the old vCard with the new information.
-
Preferences
2003-12-10 07:26:13 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Another thing with the preferences, (hint, hint to developers) is that most command shortcut key has been CMD+, which i notice on about 70% of all apps what about the rest???
-
Another nicety
2003-12-10 03:16:09 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
Nested Tab views grow gradually darker.
http://artemis.arstechnica.com/reviews/003/panther/images/nested-tabs.png
-
Dropping an icon
2003-12-09 19:21:29 anonymous2 [Reply | View]
My favorite new bit of spit & polish comes with dropping a file icon onto an folder. The icon shrinks down and moves off to the side. It looks like it is actually falling inside the folder. I put some common folders in my sidebar and it makes filing the stuff on my desktop more enjoyable with this new animation.
Jonathan -
Dropping an icon
2003-12-11 08:04:59 David Miller |
[Reply | View]
I didn't even realize that this was new in Panther; I just assumed that it was in Jaguar, as well. Anyways, it nicely complements the "puff of smoke" animation when you remove an item from the sidebar (or dock). -
Dropping an icon
2004-02-06 11:34:33 kirk_donovan [Reply | View]
What do you mean with Jaguar. Are you kidding?
________________________
Translated by:Mail -Translator






It's hard to get excited about any of this. We still run OS 9 when we can, mostly because it's very stable and the users know how it works. For the last 6 months I've run X.2.8 on my desktop because there are a few apps that require it, but it's far less usable than KDE or Windows, never mind OS9 -- HUGE graphics that are no long iconic, Desktop cluttered, big problems with AppleShare volumes. And to be honest, the OSX desktop uptime is NOT better than OS9, at least in our shop.
I've been a big fan since my fat Mac, and some of the apps in OS X are nice and innovative, but I keep thinking: the emporer has no clothes. I just don't see what the big deal is. Frankly, I would bet on linux desktop before I would buy any more Macs.