Output Like a Pro with iPhoto 5
Pages: 1, 2
Artistic Intervention
One of my complaints about iPhoto slideshows of the past can be summed with the phrase, "Lumbering Hippo." Slide after slide with the same transition, at the same pace ... it was more conducive to lulling your audience into a hypnotic trance rather than stirring their enthusiasm. First of all, I think many shows I've watched are too long. Five minutes is forever for these types of presentations. I prefer 1:30 to 3 minutes. That alone will help prevent viewers from nodding off, or at least from snoring out loud.
But you have some new tools in iPhoto 5 that can also stimulate the senses. Click once on any thumbnail in your slideshow to highlight it, then explore the options displayed beneath your picture. You can apply each effect individually to the picture you've selected. Any image that you don't change individually will use the default settings that you established earlier.
You can shift-click a sequence of images and apply effects and transitions to them as a group. This works fairly well, but the Preview button doesn't like the group selection, and just shows me the first two slides in the sequence.
The grouping is really handy if you're applying a special transition, such as the Cube, to a short sequence. For even finer tuning while the slides are selected, click on the Adjust button, and you get a handful of contextual controls for the specific transition you've applied. For example, if you're using the Cube transition, you can tell iPhoto which direction you want it to rotate by using the Adjust menu.
Figure
6. The Adjust dashboard is contextual. When you're creating slideshows, it enables
you to refine the effect.The crown jewel in this treasure chest is the Ken Burns Effect. You can apply pan and zoom effects to individual slides by clicking on their thumbnail, then checking Ken Burns Effect box. It's very easy to use, and Apple has published a short set of directions for applying this effect.
I only use the Ken Burns Effect on a handful of slides per show. That way it stays fresh. Also, be careful how much you zoom in. If you don't have tons of resolution in the picture, you might discover that it begins to pixelate as you zoom in. especially when the show plays full screen on a 17" PowerBook. But used with restraint, I think this is a terrific addition to iPhoto 5.
You can preview the effect by clicking on the Preview button. Once you have all of your slides set, click on the first thumbnail in the series, and then hit the Play button. Sit back and marvel at how good your creation looks.
Exporting to QuickTime
In theory, you can easily export your completed slideshows to QuickTime and iDVD 5. In practice, I'm having better luck right now with QuickTime than iDVD. So I'll focus on exporting to QuickTime here, and I'll come back to iDVD when it's working a little better for me.
The QuickTime export is handy for showing your presentation on computers other than where your iPhoto library lives, such as Uncle Bob's Dell PC. The procedure is simple. Click once on the slideshow object in the Source window to highlight it, then go to Sharing > Export, and iPhoto 5 figures out that you want to save the presentation as a QT movie. You have three options for frame size: 720x480, 320x240, and 240x180. But you're not afforded any compression options, so pick your frame size and location, then hit the Export button.
Figure
7. iPhoto 5 provides three size options for exporting your slideshow to QuickTime,
but no compression options.Once the file has been exported, having the Pro version of QuickTime comes in handy. Instead of viewing the movie in the (zzzzz) Player window, go to Movie > Present Movie, then choose "Normal" from the dropdown menu. Now hit the Play button. QuickTime will play your presentation in what I call movie theater mode, and it looks a lot better than watching it in the boring Player window. Try it!
Sharper Movies in Half the Size
When I exported my slideshow using the method I outlined above, the file size was 5.6MB for a 1:40 movie at 240x180. Not huge, but substantial in size. I started wondering if there was another way to export a more compact version. There is.
I went back to the custom album, "Pt. Reyes Picks," that I had created earlier (see the section titled, "Sorting Your Images"), clicked on its title once to highlight it, and clicked on the sideways triangle at the bottom of the Source window to get a dialog box (see Figure 1). This time I choose "Dissolve" for my transitions and indicated that I wanted each slide to play for 4 seconds. I clicked on the "Music" tab and selected the same song as I had been using. Then I clicked the "Save Settings" button.
Now when I go to Share > Export, I get the "old" dialog box that we saw in iPhoto 4 where I can set my frame size and duration for each image, as shown below:
Figure
8 Here's a different way to export your QuickTime movie in iPhoto 5, and with more
control.Once I click the Export button, iPhoto 5 creates a QuickTime movie and saves it in the designated place. How is this presentation different than the movie I exported earlier? Well, the file size is now 2.9MB for a 1:42 length movie with the same frame dimensions. That's almost half the size of my previous export! But it gets even better.
Method #1 (5.6MBs) used MPEG-4 compression, creating a video, tween, and audio tracks. Method #2 (2.9MBs) used Photo-JPEG compression to create its video tracks and just kept the original MP3 format of the song from my iTunes library. The upshot is, that the images in Method #2 are not only smaller in file size than with Method #1, they're sharper too. Look at the side by side comparison below:
Figure
9. Frame shot on the left was created with Photo-JPEG compression in Method #2, and
on the right with MPEG-4 compression via Method #1.This isn't a knock on the MPEG-4 codec; rather, its implementation in iPhoto 5 when exported to QuickTime. You can view the movie exported via Method #2 on my .Mac site. Some of the bird shots suffer from the small frame size, but you'll get the idea. This slideshow was exported right out of iPhoto 5 without any additional adjustments. Feel free to download it and examine its construction.
Final Thoughts
iPhoto 5 gives you some great options for creating dynamic slideshows from your images, even if you originally captured them in RAW. The new slideshow editor is terrific for customizing your presentation, then playing it full screen on your Mac.
If you want to export to QuickTime however, I recommend you create your movie directly out of your custom photo album using Photo-JPEG compression. You'll get sharper images and a smaller file size. You won't be able to intermix a variety of effects as in Method #1, but the tradeoff of a more compact download and crisper pictures might be worth sacrificing a few special effects.
This is just one example of how iPhoto 5 lets you output like a pro. Fire it up and see what you discover.
|
Related Reading Digital Photography Hacks |
Derrick Story is the author of The Photoshop CS4 Companion for Photographers, The Digital Photography Companion, and Digital Photography Hacks, and coauthor of iPhoto: The Missing Manual, with David Pogue. You can follow him on Twitter or visit www.thedigitalstory.com.
Return to MacDevCenter.com.
You must be logged in to the O'Reilly Network to post a talkback.
Showing messages 1 through 14 of 14.
-
Export to iDVD distorted
2005-02-05 17:50:18 jcteo [Reply | View]
I've been having fun with iPhoto 5 but one thing has been bugging me all day today. When exporting slideshows to iDVD, the result is distorted - squished from the sides. The problem is that the output is 720x480, a 3:2 ratio, rather than 640x480 which is the correct 4:3 aspect ratio.<br/><br/>
Anybody knows of a workaround for this? It is driving me crazy!<br/><br/>
Thanks.<br/><br/>
-Jay
-
Custom design books iPhoto5
2005-02-05 09:02:51 mozkart [Reply | View]
The iPhoto Missing Manual reveals how to adapt iPhoto books to fit them to your own needs, using developer tools (chapter 10, page 212, available on this site as a sample chapter). It seems that iPhoto 5 does not quite have the same structure of files, and I can't find the files mentioned in the book. Any hint on how to do custom designs in iPhoto 5 ?
-
Editing of RAW files
2005-02-03 15:51:57 TC! [Reply | View]
I may have misunderstood what you meant by:
"t's those JPEGs that you're editing with the slider bars in the dashboard"
But iPhoto generates a new jpeg file based on your adjustments from the original RAW file. It does not just apply the adjustments to the jpeg file it has already generated.
I confirmed this by changing the RAW file in the file system and making adjustments. When I hit done the adjustments where made to the new RAW file. -
RE: Editing of RAW files
2005-02-03 16:59:51 Derrick Story |
[Reply | View]
Well, I'll tell you what I've experienced step by step, and let you decide from there. First of all, I'm talking about working strictly within iPhoto 5 and not making any edits to any files using an outside image editor.
The original RAW file is located in the "Originals" folder. iPhoto 5 reads the data from this file to generate a jpeg that is stored in the "day of the month" folder.
When I edit a picture in the iPhoto GUI, it doesn't make any changes to the original RAW file. It does, however, generate a new jpeg in my "day of the month" folder.
Apple claims that iPhoto 5 reads data from the original RAW file when you edit with iPhoto tools, then generates a jpeg based on the changes you've specified.
So, you're not changing the RAW data itself; you're actually generating a new set of instructions for interpreting the data, that results in a new Jpeg that's displayed in the iPhoto 5 interface.
This is a somewhat confusing process, but it makes perfect sense to my mind. I should have written that sentence better. But in that section of the article, I wanted to focus on the convenience of being able to work with Jpegs and not having to go outside of iPhoto just to generate a slideshow based on RAW images.
-
Streaming Quicktime
2005-02-03 13:13:54 mweitzman [Reply | View]
Is it possible to output a Quicktime which, when posted to a web server, will stream the movie down to the client? That way, file size matters very little.
In IPhoto4, I had to export to Quicktime and then Open in QuickTime Pro and fiddle with some settings and then re-save. Would be nice if more Quicktime prefs were available during the Export from IPhoto. -
RE: Streaming Quicktime
2005-02-03 17:03:11 Derrick Story |
[Reply | View]
Unfortunately, no. You'll have to use the same workflow you developed for iPhoto 4.
-
iPhoto 5.0.1 Update
2005-02-03 08:29:24 Derrick Story |
[Reply | View]
Apple has released an update via the Software Update preference panel. I've posted a quick overview of this new version. You can now use the 'Edit in external editor" command, import .mp4 movies, and more easily drag albums into folders in the Source window.
-
Difference in Quicktime exporting
2005-02-02 22:20:06 LouM [Reply | View]
Sorry, you lost me, Derrick. How does one get the "old" export options? Is it the lack of transitions? And what's a sidways arrow (makes me think of a 'disclosure triangle' but that's obviously not what you're talking about)? Do you mean the Play button?
Maybe it's just late at night and I need some sleep... -
RE: Difference in Quicktime exporting
2005-02-02 22:34:04 Derrick Story |
[Reply | View]
Sorry Lou, I do the best I can at explaining this stuff without going into so much detail that it bores the socks off of folks. Here's what I was trying to say.
"old export options" refers to the dialog box we used in iPhoto 4 to export slideshows to QuickTime movies. If you created a slideshow and saved music with it, you could use the export function to send that content to a QuickTime movie. That dialog box still lives in iPhoto 5, as I mentioned in the article.
The "sideways triangle icon in the lower left corner of the iPhoto interface (beneath the Source window)" I refer to in paragraph 8 is technically called the "Display the slideshow" button. But I feel my description is easier to understand.
-
RAW is not always good
2005-02-02 08:04:06 MEP [Reply | View]
I'm glad that iPhoto supports RAW now, and I'm glad that people are beginnng to take digital photo processing seriously, but I'd hate for people to get the wrong idea and start thinking that RAW is necessarily better than JPEG all the time.
It really depends on your camera more than anything else whether or not you actually want to use RAW. Furthermore, if you're going to be playing with RAW files, you really should get a better photo editor than iPhoto.
All RAW really is is the direct output from a camera's CCD. It's the image before the camera's internal firmware gets a chance to process it. For some photographers, this is a good thing because a few minutes in Photoshop can create much better images from the RAW output than the camera's chintzy little firmware can.
So if you're shooting with say a Konica Minolta DiMage Z2, then you're better off using RAW files because the camera's internal image processor has a strong tendency to create lots of noise and compression artifacts. But if you're shooting with an Olympus C8080WZ, you really should just shoot in JPEG mode because that camera's internal firmware does an amazing job producing great looking pictures in even the toughest lighting conditions. In order for you to take the RAW image into Photoshop (or iPhoto) and do as good a job as the camera does on its own, you would have to spend a significant amount of your time tweaking it.
RAW support is a really great thing and for professional photographers or really serious hobbyists it allows you to take some great pictures that otherwise would be troublesome with most digital cameras. That being said, sometimes you really are better off just using high quality JPEG compression in the camera's firmware and if you really want to take advantage of all that RAW has to offer, you're going to need a stronger tool than iPhoto.
At most the RAW support in iPhoto means that hobbyists can now catalog their RAW files along with all of the other images they catalog in iPhoto which makes it more convenient to use and organize their photo collections. But anyone who was using RAW files before this iPhoto update already has Photoshop or Photoshop Elements, both of which are much better for editing RAW and for importing RAW files from your camera. -
RAW is not always good
2005-02-15 05:34:58 Marook [Reply | View]
Well, I don't know about the two camera's you mention, but the Canon 300D stores 1) a jpeg processed version in the RAW file and 2) all the settings used to re-generate the image - ie. the 'default' settings for the shooting time.
So, in my case, iPhoto will make the same image as the Canon camera does - but I get the RAW data too. -
RE: RAW is not always good
2005-02-02 08:40:23 Derrick Story |
[Reply | View]
Or to but a duller point on it, choose the best format for the job. MEP makes some good points, and as I've confessed online many times, I shoot JPEG more than RAW.
That being said, those of us who like iPhoto haven't really had the option to work with RAW format within our chosen workflow. So now that iPhoto 5 supports the storage and retrieval of these files, not to mention some convenient editing tools, it's fun to explore the new capabilities.
In the end, our readers can decide which format is best for them in any given situation.







Does anyone know what I need to do to do a conversion?
Thanks,